Skip to main content

Journal of Population Sciences

Table 3 Multi-level estimates of grandchild caring patterns on the depressive symptoms of grandparents, 2012–2018. Source: Authors’ analysis of the Harmonised SHARE Waves 4–7

From: The impact of grandchild care provision on grandparents’ depressive symptoms across Europe using multi-level analysis: do the grandchild caring patterns and the country’s economy matter?

 

Intercept-only model

Random-intercept models

Random-intercept models with cross-level interactions

Response: Depressive symptoms

Model 1:

Full sample

Model 2:

Full sample

Model 3: Grandfathers

Model 4: Grandmothers

Model 5:

Full sample

Model 6: Grandfathers

Model 7: Grandmothers

Parameter

Estimate

Std. Err

Estimate

Std. Err

Estimate

Std. Err

Estimate

Std. Err

Estimate

Std. Err

Estimate

Std. Err

Estimate

Std. Err

Fixed part

 β0

Intercept

2.61***

0.16

1.54

2.16

1.04

1.70

2.69**

2.54

2.49

2.18

1.48*

1.75

3.75***

2.57

 β1

Previous or less intensive carers (ref: non-carers)

− 0.07**

0.03

− 0.08*

0.04

− 0.06

0.04

− 2.59***

0.63

− 1.09**

0.05

− 2.76***

0.85

 β2

New or more intensive carers (ref: non-carers)

− 0.03

0.03

− 0.04

0.05

− 0.03

0.04

− 1.34*

0.76

− 0.98***

0.44

− 1.42***

1.01

 β3

Repeated carers (ref: non-carers)

− 0.11

0.03

− 0.12**

0.04

− 0.10*

0.04

− 0.74

0.67

− 0.69***

0.42

− 1.46***

0.87

 β4

Age (centred at 60)

− 0.02***

0.00

− 0.03***

0.01

− 0.02***

0.01

− 0.02**

0.01

− 0.03***

0.01

− 0.02***

0.01

 β5

Age squared

  

0.001***

0.00

0.001***

0.00

0.001*

0.00

0.001***

0.01

0.001***

0.00

0.001***

0.00

 β6

Gender (ref: male)

0.69***

0.03

0.69***

0.03

 β7

Marital status (ref: not married)

− 0.21***

0.03

− 0.30***

0.04

− 0.18***

0.03

− 0.21***

0.03

− 0.32***

0.04

− 0.18***

0.03

 β8

Education attainment: Upper secondary (ref: less than lower secondary)

− 0.19***

0.03

− 0.12**

0.04

− 0.23**

0.04

− 0.19***

0.03

− 0.12**

0.01

− 0.23***

0.04

 β9

Education attainment: Tertiary (ref: less than lower secondary)

− 0.20***

0.04

− 0.14**

0.05

− 0.25**

0.05

− 0.20***

0.04

− 0.14**

0.01

− 0.25***

0.05

 β10

Currently working (ref: not working)

− 0.07*

0.03

− 0.04

0.05

− 0.10

0.04

− 0.07*

0.03

− 0.07

0.05

− 0.10*

0.04

 β11

Number of grandchildren

0.01**

0.00

0.02**

0.01

0.01

0.01

0.01*

0.00

0.02***

0.01

0.01

0.01

 β12

Co-residing with children (ref: no)

0.01

0.03

0.06

0.05

− 0.01

0.04

0.01

0.03

0.03

0.05

− 0.02

0.04

 β13

Self-rated health

0.70***

0.01

0.62***

0.02

0.75***

0.02

0.70***

0.01

0.63***

0.02

0.75***

0.02

 β14

ADL functional status

0.26***

0.02

0.28***

0.03

0.24***

0.02

0.26***

0.02

0.29***

0.03

0.24***

0.02

 β15

IADL functional status

0.18***

0.02

0.17***

0.03

0.18***

0.02

0.17***

0.02

0.16***

0.03

0.18***

0.02

 β16

Household income

− 0.06**

0.02

− 0.10***

0.03

− 0.09***

0.03

− 0.06**

0.02

− 0.10***

0.03

− 0.09**

0.03

 β17

GDP

− 0.14*

0.08

− 0.70**

0.28

− 0.20*

0.11

− 0.23*

0.10

− 0.15*

0.08

− 0.30**

0.24

 β18

GDP X Previous or less intensive carers

0.24***

0.03

0.13**

0.05

0.26***

0.04

 β19

GDP X New or more intensive carers

0.11**

0.04

0.12*

0.06

0.14*

0.05

 β20

GDP X Repeated carers

0.12*

0.04

0.08

0.05

0.13*

0.05

Random part

              

\({\sigma }_{\mathrm{v}0}^{2}\)

Country variance

0.37

0.14

0.10

0.04

0.06

0.03

0.13

0.05

0.10

0.04

0.06

0.03

0.13

0.06

\({\sigma }_{\upmu }^{2}\)

Individual variance

2.46

0.03

1.56

0.03

1.27

0.05

1.74

0.05

1.56

0.03

1.26

0.05

1.74

0.04

\({\sigma }_{e}^{2}\)

Residual variance

2.56

0.02

2.25

0.03

1.97

0.04

2.44

0.04

2.25

0.03

1.97

0.04

2.44

0.03

Intraclass Coefficient (ICC)

              

 Country

6.9%

2.4%

1.8%

3.1%

43.5%

2.5%

1.8%

3.1%

 Individual

52.5%

42.5%

40.2%

42.4%

40.1%

43.4%

 AIC

282,393

165,796

59,410

106,067

165,799

59,419

106,074

 BIC

282,430

165,968

59,555

106,221

165,997

59,587

106,253

 Number of countries

13

13

13

13

13

13

13

 Number of respondents

24,656

24,656

9,524

15,132

24,656

9,524

15,132

 Number of observations

66,504

66,504

25,102

41,402

66,504

25,102

41,402

  1. All models were based on Restricted Maximum Likelihood (REML) estimation. Std Err: standard error; AIC: Akaike Information Criterion; BIC: Bayesian Information Criterion; Model 1 was based on the intercept-only model, Models 2–4 were based on the random-intercept models, and Models 5–7 were based on the random-intercept models with cross-level interactions. AIC and BIC were provided for information only and were not comparable between models under REML estimates.
  2. *Significant at the 5% level; ** Significant at the 1% level; *** Significant at the 0.1% level.